BC's Unsold Condo Tax: What Eby Proposed and Why Developers Object

A promise made in the first week of British Columbia's snap election campaign is now one of the most debated housing ideas in Canada. NDP Leader and Premier David Eby has said that, if re-elected on October 24, his government would tax newly built condos that sit unsold.
What is proposed
-
The tax: 2% of a condo's assessed value for new units left empty for more than a year
-
The ramp: the rate rises by one percentage point for each extra year the unit stays empty, so a condo vacant for three years would face 3%
-
Speculation and vacancy tax: raised by one point, to 2% for domestic owners and 5% for foreign buyers
-
The aim: push developers to cut prices and sell finished homes
The numbers behind it
Eby said the tax would target about 5,000 vacant, unsold condos in Metro Vancouver, citing an analysis by Real Property Data that put their value at roughly $4.4 to $4.6 billion. He pointed to a Burnaby building he described as 76% vacant.
Why the counts differ
Other commentators have used other figures. One estimate puts newly completed unsold condos in the Vancouver region at about 4,000. Another counts 8,400 unsold new units in Metro Vancouver that are either under construction or already complete. The totals differ mostly because they include different stages of construction.
The pushback
Developers have reacted with anger, saying they have already paid hefty fees and carry high costs on units they cannot sell. Simon Fraser University finance professor Andrey Pavlov said the tax might lower prices in the short term but could have severe unintended consequences, and could even encourage developers to delay finishing projects. The BC Real Estate Association's chief economist said the policy could have disastrous potential. The Conservatives have also criticised it.
The market context
Metro Vancouver recorded 1,717 sales in September, down 8.4% from last year, and apartment sales fell 18.6%. The federal and provincial governments are also looking at a plan to buy more than 2,220 vacant condos to convert into affordable housing.
What to watch
The vote on October 24 decides whether the proposal becomes policy. Any design changes would likely come after that.